Indoor Cycling vs Running: Differences & How to Choose the Best for Your Needs
Posted on
When it comes to starting a cardiovascular fitness journey, two of the most popular options are cycling and running. That’s why you’ll often find plenty of treadmills and stationary bikes in any gym. As a personal trainer with years of experience on the gym floor, I’ve been asked countless times: “Should I be doing indoor cycling or running?†It’s a common question, and it makes sense — choosing between the two can be confusing. Both have their own unique benefits, and the decision ultimately depends on your goals, preferences, and lifestyle.
In this article, I’ll break down the key differences between cycling and running so you can make an informed choice. If you’d like to see a visual comparison, check out my YouTube video where I dive deeper into the pros and cons of each.
**Accessibility**
One of the first things to consider is accessibility. While both activities are available at the gym, home setups differ. A stationary bike is generally more affordable and easier to store than a treadmill. Treadmills can be expensive, especially if you want a high-quality model. On the other hand, running doesn’t require any equipment — just a pair of shoes. That said, cycling can also be done outdoors, giving you more flexibility if you prefer fresh air.
**Muscles Used**
Both running and cycling work the lower body, but they target different muscle groups. Running engages the core more and puts greater pressure on the hamstrings and calves. Cycling, on the other hand, focuses on the quads and glutes, and even uses the upper body for balance and control when standing. So, if you're looking to build leg strength, cycling might be better, while running offers a stronger core workout.
**Workout Intensity**
Cycling allows for a wider range of intensities. You can cycle gently or push yourself to the limit, making it great for varied workouts. Running, by contrast, tends to be more intense from the start, which means shorter sessions and longer recovery periods. However, both activities can burn a lot of calories — between 200 and 900 per hour, depending on how hard you work.
**Dynamics**
Cycling offers more dynamic movement options. You can change cadence, shift positions, adjust resistance, and even vary your hand placement. Running, while effective, is more straightforward — mostly about speed and incline. If you enjoy variety in your workouts, cycling might be the way to go.
**Smart Training**
Indoor cycling has seen a big rise in smart technology. Brands like Peloton and NordicTrack offer interactive classes, live sessions, and competitive leaderboards. Treadmills are catching up, but they still lag behind in terms of interactive features and user engagement.
**Recovery**
Cycling is typically easier on the joints and allows for quicker recovery. Many cyclists do daily rides, even recovery ones. Running, due to its higher impact, often requires more rest time between sessions. This can affect how frequently you can train.
**Which Is For You?**
At the end of the day, it all comes down to what you enjoy. If you love the feeling of running, stick with it. If you prefer the rhythm of pedaling, then cycling is the way to go. Enjoyment plays a huge role in consistency. That said, cycling offers more versatility in intensity, recovery, and tech features, while running provides a quick, high-intensity option that needs no equipment.
So, whether you're lacing up your sneakers or hopping on a bike, the most important thing is to keep moving — and most importantly, have fun doing it!